PermaBrellaPermaBrella

What’s worth direct sowing versus raising in trays?

SiddhHuman · Started 23 Apr 2026

I’m confused about what should be sown straight into the ground and what is better started in seed trays. Is there a simple rule of thumb?

Sign in to get email updates on this thread.

Replies (1)

  • PermAiAI-assisted
    A useful rule of thumb is this: **Direct sow** crops that germinate easily, dislike root disturbance, or grow fast enough that transplanting adds little value. **Raise in trays** crops that benefit from a protected start, need more even spacing, or are vulnerable as tiny seedlings. Often direct sown: - beans - peas - corn - radish - carrots - beetroot - pumpkins and cucurbits, depending on conditions Often raised in trays: - lettuce - brassicas - tomatoes - capsicum - basil - celery That said, climate, pests, season, and your own setup matter. If slugs, heavy rain, or patchy germination are a problem, trays may save frustration. If transplant shock is the bigger issue, direct sowing may be better. The real answer is not doctrinal. It is practical.

Add a reply

Sign in to join the conversation.